Best Propane Gas Smokers Reviews From Amazon-Top 10 (Updated 2024)

Everyone loves perfectly smoked meat and vegetables for a leisurely afternoon. Many foodies purchase a wood smoker to get the exact flavour of restaurant-smoked meat, but the inconvenience is at its peak with a wood smoker. Instead, choosing the best propane smoker for meat and vegetables is a great option. Instead of wasting your money on buying hickory or Applewood, purchase the best propane meat smoke, and you’re good to go.

Many varieties of meat require different smoking times to reach perfection, and with wood smokers, only advanced cooks can achieve the exact smoke amount and time. But that’s not an issue with the propane meat smoker as you can set the knob to increase or decrease the amount of smoke reaching the meat and seer it to perfection. Wake up the Chef inside you and choose the Best Propane Smoker to smoke the meat and enjoy your backyard barbecue sessions with friends and family members.

This is one of the top 10 best propane gas smokers reviews that you will find anywhere. We will explain what a gas smoker is, how it works, why you should get one and tell you which top-rated gas smokers are and why.

Comparison Of Best Propane Gas Smokers With Reviews From Amazon: Updated 2024

What is Gas Smoker?

If you like your meat to be tenderized and rich in flavour then a gas smoker is for you. You can use low heat and strong smoke to give your meat a flavour that is out of this world. It is a lot more convenient to use a gas smoker than other types of smokers.

Gas smokers are easy to use. It doesn’t matter if you are new to smoking food or have years of experience. Most modern gas smokers have a rectangular box-shaped appearance and they have doors and shelves for easy access. The gas burner is located at the bottom of the smoker and there will be a tray to place your wood chips, smoking chips or sawdust.

How Does Propane Gas Smoker Work?

When a gas smoker is in use the heat provided by the gas burner goes through lava rocks before it reaches the food chamber above. These lava rocks provide the substrate that you need to make your wood chips or pellets smoulder and produce smoke. You may see other materials used other than lava rocks in some smokers.

In between the smoke and the heat and the food, a chamber is a bath of water that introduces humidity. This bath will also capture any drippings from the food above. You do not want these drippings to fall onto the gas burner. The water bath will help with smoke dispersal as well.

There will be an outlet vent on the top of the gas smoker for the smoke to escape into the air. Within the food chamber, you will find a number of racks where you can place food. It sounds great to have a larger food chamber as you can cook more food, but you need to bear in mind that with a larger chamber, you will need to use more energy to cook everything.

Is A Propane Gas Smoker A Good Idea?

There are a number of benefits to using a propane gas smoker:

• Propane gas is very efficient in producing smoke
• Gas is a good supplementary heat source
• You will get a clean burn with propane gas
• The byproducts of propane gas are just carbon dioxide and water
• It is quick to set up a propane gas smoker
• You have more control with a gas smoker. Temperature control is easier than with some other smokers

Things to Consider Before Purchasing A Propane Gas Smokers: Best Buying Guide

If you want to buy the best propane smoker then you need to think about a number of different factors.

Cooking Capacity – what will you use your gas smoker for? Is it just for the family or do you want to invite many people over for a barbeque party? Get the gas smoker that has the right cooking capacity for you.

Build Quality – a gas smoker is not cheap so you want it to last as long as possible. You will be using it outdoors so it will need to withstand all kinds of temperatures as well as moisture. We would always recommend paying a bit more for a higher-quality gas smoker.

Temperature Control – best-smoked food cooking comes from constant temperatures. It is important that you can control the cooking temperature and make minor adjustments if necessary.

Monitoring Window – you need to keep an eye on your cooking no matter how good the manufacturer claims the consistency of the temperature is. We would, therefore, recommend gas smokers that have viewing windows.

Gas Burners – look at the power output of the gas burners measured in BTU. An automatic ignition system is useful as lighting gas burners without this can be a challenge.

Best Propane Gas Smokers Reviews From Amazon: Top 10

Here we will review the top-rated gas smokers available on Amazon. We will start with the best propane smoker and then look at the other best smokers for 2023. This is one of the most comprehensive propane smoke reviews you will ever read. So let’s get on with it.

1. The Masterbuilt 20050614 Propane Smoker Black Review : (Editor’s Choice for Best Propane Gas Smoker)

A lot of customers have purchased this Masterbuilt gas smoker and are very happy with it for good reason. If you love a barbecue then you will love the large capacity that the Masterbuilt 20050614 has to offer. There are four racks for cooking and a capacity of 2,000 square inches. It’s great for those barbeque days with lots of guests.

If you want to cook over 50 burgers at a time this is no problem. You can even cook over 110 sausages. You can fit around 20 chickens, 8 racks of ribs, 6 turkeys or 16 pork butts into your smoker. It is ideal for parties.

The Masterbuild has a superior design quality and there are two doors with a viewing window in the top door. This allows you to check the amount of smoke to ensure there is no burning of your food. There are two powerful burners rated at 8,250 BTU and the smoker is strong and durable and made from stainless steel.

Lighting the burners is easy thanks to the push-button ignition system. The controls are also easy to use. Unlike some smokers access to the tray of smoking, materials are easy. The tray is removable and you will not affect the temperature when replenishing. You can do the same with the water bath as well.

You can attach wheels to this smoker to make it easy to move around. Cleaning the Masterbuild is really easy Just use a damp cloth to have your smoker clean again.

BUY NOW AT AMAZON

Here Are The Pros And Cons Of The Masterbuild 20050614 Propane Smoker Black:

READ MORE REVIEWS AT AMAZON 

2. The Smoke Hollow PS4415 Pro Series Propane Smoker Review

This is another gas smoker which provides a large capacity for cooking your food. The Smoke Hollow 33-inch measures 33.3 by 24.5 by 60.8 inches and weighs around 100 pounds. The capacity of this smoker is 6 cubic feet according to the manufacturer.

There are five racks available for cooking so you have plenty of options here. You can remove some of the racks to cook large items such as chickens and turkeys. Use the racks for sausages, burgers, chops and so on.

The Smoke Hollow has two independently controlled and powerful gas burners. They have a capacity of 11,000 BTU so there is plenty of heat potential there. There are also two chip trays for smoking that you load externally. The water pan has a porcelain coating and the smoker has a high-quality heat indicator so that you are always in control.

There is a viewing window in the door which makes monitoring your cooking very easy. You can vary the heat to cook whatever you want such as barbeque ribs, or smoked fish and you can even create jerky. The smoker is well made and very durable and will last you a long time. This smoker retains heat well due to its well-insulated design.

BUY NOW AT AMAZON

Here Are The Pros And Cons Of The Smoke Hollow PS4415 Pro Series:

READ MORE REVIEWS AT AMAZON 

3. Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36″ Vertical LP Gas Smoker Review

The Dyna-Glo is a nice gas smoker that provides 784 square inches of cooking capacity. There are four steel racks included that you can adjust as you wish. Your food will have a great smoky taste after using this smoker that everyone will enjoy.

There is a single cast iron gas burner that has an output of 15,000 BTU. The electronic push-button ignition makes it easy to ignite the burner. At the bottom of the smoker is a large dial for controlling the temperature. The single wood chip tray has a porcelain enamel coating.

There are two doors with the Dyna-Glo smoker but there is no viewing window. The design and construction of this smoker are good and this durable unit will last a long time. There are three vents provided for fine temperature control without having to adjust the burner flame.

The Assembly of this gas smoker is straightforward and the user manual is easy to follow. The racks are all removable which helps to make cooking more convenient. Due to its smaller size, this smoker only weighs around 54 pounds so it is easier to move around than the larger smokers.

This unit produces good smoke and the temperature is fairly easy to maintain. It will produce good results time after time but can take a bit of getting used to especially if you are new to smokers.

BUY NOW AT AMAZON

Here Are The Pros And Cons Of The Dyna-Glo:

READ MORE REVIEWS AT AMAZON 

4. Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36″ Propane Gas Smoker Review

Cuisinart is a name that you can trust when it comes to cooking. They produce a number of different high-quality products and the COS-244 is another one of these. This gas smoker does not have the cooking capacity of some of the larger smokers but it does have some very good features. The cooking capacity is around 5 square feet.

The Cuisinart comes with four racks which measure 14 by 14 inches. This is a good size for all kinds of cooking. You can smoke cuts of meat, burgers, sausages and your favourite vegetables easily.

A well-designed and well-made smoker as you would expect from Cuisinart. You will get consistent cooking results every time. The doors on this smoker have a very tight seal so that the heat remains inside. There is a large control knob for the burner at the bottom.

Both the water bath and the wood chip tray have a porcelain coating for durability. The smoker comes with a 40-inch hose that has a regulator for easy connection to propane tanks. You can regulate the supply of gas while you are cooking which gives you additional control.

BUY NOW AT AMAZON

Here Are The Pros And Cons Of The Cuisinart COS-244:

READ MORE REVIEWS AT AMAZON 

5. Landmann USA 3495GLA Smoky Mountain Vertical Gas Smoker Review

The Landmann USA 3495GLA is certainly a heavy-duty smoker. It is a very strong and durable unit made from good quality steel for a sturdy construction. The base of this gas smoker is wide and offers very good stability which is important for cooking outdoors.

The gas burner has a powerful 13,500 BTU output. You can fully control the heat that you apply using the knob at the bottom of the smoker. There is a temperature gauge on the front door to help you monitor your cooking.

The doors on the Landmann have magnetic closures which help to keep the heat in. They also make opening and closing the doors easy. There are four cooking racks provided and these have a chrome coating. You can adjust the positions of the shelves to accommodate different sizes of meat.

The Landmann has a meat hanger which is useful for creating dried meat. There are drawers to access the smoke material tray and water bath conveniently. Lighting the gas burner is easy with the rotary igniter.

BUY NOW AT AMAZON

The Landmann USA 3495GLA Has The Following Pros And Cons:

READ MORE REVIEWS AT AMAZON 

6. Smoke Hollow 38202G 38-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker Review

This is another large smoker from Smoke Hollow. It provides 3.4 cubic feet of cooking capacity. The smoker comes with four cooking grids that have been chrome plated. You can adjust the positions of the grids easily as there are several adjustment levels.

The gas burner is cast brass and is very powerful with an output of 20,000 BTU. It is easy to light the burner due to the push button ignition facility. You have a control knob that enables you to adjust the heat levels.

Both the water bath and wood chip pan are easily accessible through the second door of this unit. These are porcelain coated for increased durability. The smoker has a good build quality and is very durable. This Smoke Hollow smoker measures 38 x 20 x 14 inches and weighs around 70 pounds.

You will find a temperature gauge included with this unit. You can further control the temperature thanks to the upper and lower vents in the smoker. The doors on this model have a sure lock system and the spring wire handles remain cool to the touch.

BUY NOW AT AMAZON

Here Are The Pros And Cons Of The Smoke Hollow 38202G:

READ MORE REVIEWS AT AMAZON 

7. Char-Broil Vertical Liquid Propane Gas Smoker Review

This smoker from Char-Grill has a lot of cooking space. The manufacturers claim that there are over 7,500 cubic inches of space for cooking which makes this a giant among smokers. The three chrome-plated cooking grid shelves allow you to place different thicknesses of meats in the smoker.

The efficient gas burner has a convenient control for regulating the cooking temperature. It is simple to set the knob at the required temperature to obtain the results that you want. You will use the same knob to ignite the burner.

Both the wood chip pan and the water bath have a unique design. Porcelain coating provides extra durability. A well-made smoker, the Char-Broil also has a damper at the top. If you open the damper then the temperature will rise. There is also a grate on top which you do not see on any gas smokers. You can use this to warm sauces or marinades in a pot.

The handles on the Char-Broil are chrome springs that always remain cool. This smoker delivers consistent heat which will provide predictable cooking results. It delivers a very nice smoky taste.

BUY NOW AT AMAZON

Here Are The Pros And Cons Of The Char-Grill:

READ MORE REVIEWS AT AMAZON 

8. Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker Review

This Masterbuilt Thermotemp gas smoker does not have the cooking capacity of some of the larger smokers but it is still worthy of consideration. There is an automatic shut-off valve with this gas smoker which is a good safety feature. You will get four cooking racks with this Masterbuilt model.

The temperature is thermostatically controlled. This means that you do not have to worry about making manual adjustments. All of the controls are easy to use and there is an ignition system for easy lighting of the burner. A really good feature of this model is a gauge which shows you how much gas you have left.

There are two doors and the top door has a viewing window. You can add wood chips without affecting the temperature via the lower door. Although the capacity for cooking is not that large you can still successfully cook 12 chickens, 4 racks of ribs, 48 sausages, 32 burgers or 2 turkeys.

As you would expect from Masterbuilt the build quality is very good. You can rely on the Thermotemp model to provide consistent cooking results with a great smoky taste.

BUY NOW AT AMAZON

Here Are The Pros And Cons Of The Masterbuilt Thermotemp:

READ MORE REVIEWS AT AMAZON 

9. Pit Boss Grills 77435 Vertical LP Gas Smoker Review

This Pit Boss gas smoker comes with a good cooking capacity and powerful burners. The gas burners will output up to 13,500 BTU. There is a glass panel on the door which you can use to monitor your cooking and check on the burners.

The door on this Pit Boss Grills model includes a high-temperature seal to minimize smoke and heat escape. You will receive four cooking racks and these are all porcelain-coated. You have a cooking area of 676 square feet which is enough for most users.

It is easy to add more wood chips to the tray without interrupting the cooking process. This model creates an even amount of smoke in the food chamber. You can control the temperature of this smoker easily. The ignition system makes lighting the burners simple as well.

The temperature of this gas smoker is controllable from 100 to 300 degrees. This is a simple smoker to use that produces good cooking results. It weighs around 50 pounds and measures 21.5 by 23 by 47 inches.

BUY NOW AT AMAZON

Here Are The Pros And Cons Of The Pit Boss Grills 77435:

READ MORE REVIEWS AT AMAZON 

10. Weston 36-Inch Outdoor Propane Vertical Smoker Review

The Weston Vertical gas smoker is the last to enter our review. It has a powerful gas burner that will output up to 9,000 BTU. You can easily light the burner with the rotary igniter. The cooking space is not as large as other gas smokers but you can cook quite a lot of food with this model.

This gas smoker has a stainless steel construction which is durable. The water tray has a porcelain coat so that it won’t rust and there is a wood chip tray in the cast iron base. You get four cooking racks with this model and they are all adjustable and removable as well as chrome plated.

You can cook around 14 pounds of food with the supplied racks. There are also two sausage hooks for more convenient cooking. The unit has a single door that has locking clamps that help to minimize heat and smoke escapes.

The door has a temperature gauge built-in and there are three dampers you can use to adjust the heat and smoke levels. At 81 pounds the Weston is a fairly heavy unit but there are two heavy-duty handles to help with the carrying.

BUY NOW AT AMAZON

Here Are The Pros And Cons Of The Weston Vertical Gas Smoker:

READ MORE REVIEWS AT AMAZON 

How To Use A Propane Gas Smoker?

All gas smokers come with instructions from the manufacturer. It is very important that you read these instructions before using your gas smoker for the first time. We recommend that you put your new smoker through a “dry run” before you start cooking. This will burn off any residues or oils used in manufacturing.

The first step is to fill the water bath. You do not have to put water in the bath and you could go for beer or cider instead of extra flavour. As fat will drip into the bath add a foil liner first for easy cleaning. Add wood chips to the tray.

Now you need to connect your propane tank and turn the valve on. Open the door where the burner is located and light it following the instructions from the manufacturer. Once the burner has a flame you can use the controller to set the temperature that you want. Some burners will have a low, medium or high setting so check how this relates to temperature.

You want to preheat your smoker for around 10 to 15 minutes. Use the chimney damper or the vents provided to achieve a steady temperature. After the initial preheat you need to add your smoking materials. Keep the preheating going until you see billowing smoke from the dampers or the chimney.

Now you can add your food to the shelves. Some gas smokers have hooks that you can use to hang food items. While everything is cooking periodically check to see if the water bath needs replenishment or you need to add more smoking material to the wood chip tray. Keep an eye on the gas too to make sure it doesn’t run out.

After you have cooked your food for the desired length of time take it out of the food chamber. Turn off the gas burner and disconnect the LPG tank. Let the smoker cool down and then clean it.

Propane Gas Smoker Vs Electric Smoker

One of the biggest advantages of a gas smoker over an electric smoker is that it uses a real flame to cook the food. Electric smokers do not have this and the taste is not as good. The wood chips in an electric smoker will only smoulder. That delicious crunchiness that you get with a gas smoker is not there with electric smokers.

Using electricity outdoors can be very dangerous. Although most electric smokers have safety features there is still a possibility of danger. You can use a gas smoker in all weathers and it will always be safe.

What Are The Best Propane Smoker Brands On The Market?

In our opinion the top gas smoker brands are:

• Master built
• Cuisinart
• Smoke Hollow
• Landmann
• Char-Broil
• Pit Boss Grills
• Dyna Glo

Frequently Asked Questions for Best Propane Gas Smokers-FAQ

Q1.Why is a propane gas smoker a good idea?

Propane provides a clean burn and is very efficient at creating smoke for cooking.

Q2.Why is the water bath necessary?

This provides humidity for better cooking results.

Q3.What kind of smoke materials can you use?

Most gas smokers will use wood chips but in some cases, you can use other materials. Check the manufacturer’s specification on this.

Q4.Why is a monitoring window important?

Gas smokers are usually pretty efficient but it always pays dividends to check the smoke levels periodically. If there is no monitoring window you have to open the door to do this which will let the heat out.

Q5.Why are some gas smokers more expensive than others?

This is mainly due to the quality of the smoker. Other factors such as cooking capacity and the level of control will be a factor.

Q6.How long will a gas smoker last?

A good quality gas smoker will last for years. The old adage of “you get what you pay for” is certainly true with gas smokers.

Q7.What is the major benefit of owning a gas smoker?

Great tasting smoky food!

Final Words For Best Propane Gas Smokers Reviews

We hope that you have enjoyed reading this best propane smoker review. In our opinion, the best propane smoker 2023 available through Amazon is the Masterbuilt 20050614 Propane Smoker 44 Inch Black. It is a fine-quality gas smoker that has all of the features that you could ever wish for.

Among the other top-rated gas smokers are the Smoke Hollow PS4415 Pro and the Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP. The Cuisinart smoker is worthy of consideration too. The more money you are prepared to invest the better smoker you will end up with. It is as simple as that. We wish you happy gas smoking in 2024.